世外

首先唔好以睇動畫王國日本出品嘅鬼滅之刃心態入場，技術/經驗層面同製作預算完全係兩回事，不能直接比較。從技術層面睇，我認為本作美術設計、人設、分鏡、背景美術，電腦特效、配樂、音效等都能做到合格有餘，上得戲院，出得國際。但並非冇彈嘅地方，就係劇情比較跳，觀眾比較難follow，亦由於劇情跳躍於不同時代同國度，牽涉人物較多但不夠深刻，都好似流水式過場咁，共鳴感唔大。而主角小鬼同小妹之間由冇感情變到有感情處理上唔夠感染力打動觀眾。配音方面，搵當紅演員配音好處係加強號召力同宣傳效果，但壊處係有機會另觀眾出戲。唔係話張繼聰配得好定唔好，但角色黑天一開聲，我就成個張繼聰喺我個腦海中出現一直到完場，好抽離。唔係針對張繼聰，而係動畫是否必須要用當紅見慣聽熟嘅明星去聲演呢？值得思考。整體本片係值得入場睇嘅，希望會有好成績，亦希望香港動畫能成為一個產業，不停有原創作品推出，又或者動畫版九龍城寨、破地獄、風雲.....反攻日本。PS. （含劇透）• 食細佬道德倫理上好震撼，冇修飾，夠赤裸，我 like 呢條橋• 角色、道具喺設定時可考慮埋市場商品/玩具化銷售，好似笨大咁• 張繼聰先生，我係純建設性討論，冇偏見、冇針對，如有得罪，請多多包函。🙏事實我都好鍾意睇你攪笑喜劇。😄• 本片將會於日本發行

在Staff表看到這麼多的香港人是感動的。這道電車難題的選擇⋯只能說這是小鬼的故事⋯The miracle of circle of life…動畫分鏡人設是出色，最後戲院開燈的時機著實地聰明

本身要支持本地製作，但偏偏配音令到好難入戲，個個都係讀稿feel咁，完全唔入戲，柯先生既配音技巧簡直就係嚴重災區，同謝師奶講仙氣唔代表係平鋪讀對白，仲有佢老公過份high既演繹，都完全唔可以令角色昇華，反而令人出戲，人名都唔好個個都小咩小麥咁啦，戲本身劇情可以既，但仍有好多進步空間。

It is crazy to believe Another World is a Hong Kong production considering how unprecedented it feels. It is an imaginative labour of love, a technical marvel and an emotional powerhouse. The quality is off the charts, there’s no denying that its 7 years of production time bleeds through the screen.The world building, themes of incarnation and visual designs are all exceptional. The filmmaker delivers a stunning plot revelation, and multiple super hard-hitting moments that put me near the brink of tearing up…Unfortunately the movie also stubs its toes by having really amateurish voice performance. Not gonna lie, this is among the rarest examples of an animation feature that suffers from a voice acting problem. You don’t know how important it is until it is not done right. Even though I really really want to like the movie due to its spellbinding visuals and evocative music, I couldn’t bring myself to immerse in the story at all due to the flat, forced-sounding voice acting. This is a classic example of “I can tell they are trying super hard, but it just doesn’t work.”Apart from this major criticism, I also think the first half of the movie is very uneven. You can argue the final revelation justifies its sporadical structure, but I think the ends don’t justify the means, at least not to the extent that it borderlines on boring, inconsistent and overtly forced. I can’t help but wonder the story would probably flows a lot better if they don’t over explain the expositions, and let the visuals do the talking.I also think the actual meat of the story is quite superficial and cliche even though the plot revelation is unique and well done. The core relationships focus too much on “form” rather than actual character development. Character motivations are vague and thin at best, the directing and visual-music marriage do a lot of heavy lifting.I also think the movie ends somewhat poorly. The last scene should be cut and the end credits (although separately is a nice song) fits poorly with the melodramatic tone of the movie.Overall this movie is still a much appreciated and needed animation miracle from Hong Kong. Just one that is quite flawed.Verdict: 78

高層次的動畫，須要慢慢思考當中的意義。也許一切要放下執念才能前進。

十粒推薦個世界觀個善惡觀震撼人心